Some Missouri republicans would like Missouri Attorney General Josh Hawley to do more in his race to unseat incumbent Democrat Senator Claire McCaskill. But others point out his race is deadlocked against an entrenched politician. Not bad for someone who has only been in office for two years with one of the busiest schedules around.
And that on top of the fact Hawley has had a caseload that would overwhelm attorney generals from many other states.
As the state’s chief legal officer, he’s known for pursuing some lawsuits against some big names like Google and Facebook. He’s driven by a belief in conservative policies but has also immersed his office in non-partisan priorities to the benefit of the state.
State litigation
Hawley’s office is investigating July’s Duck Boat tragedy in Branson that took 17 lives and is suing business’s owners and operators. The legal action is being taken under the Missouri Merchandising Practices Act which provides consumer-protections.
This past Monday, Hawley filed court documents to counter the defendants’ motion to dismiss the case and move it to federal court. The filing stated that defense actions were an effort to “hamper and delay the State’s enforcement action”. Hawley also pushed back on the defendants’ contention that they’re only subject to the regulation and oversight of the U.S. Coast Guard, saying the state is instead focused on fraudulent, misleading, and deceptive trade practices. “Their misconduct is regulated by the Missouri Merchandising Practices Act and subject to the oversight of the Missouri Attorney General,” said Hawley.
The suit alleges that the defendants made, “misrepresentations to consumers that safety was a top priority when in actuality it was their own profits.” Hawley thinks the fact that two boats were in the water during a severe thunderstorm warning reflects a practice of putting profits over safety.
“We believe that the companies have a policy of refunding the ticket price to consumers if the tour boat does not enter the water,” said Hawley. “So, the companies had a strong financial incentive to actually get these boats out into the water even though there was significant adverse weather.”
The lawsuit asks the court to block the owners from operating Duck Boats in the state until further notice. Hawley contends the vessels pose a risk to citizens.
In addition, Hawley recently sued a southeast Missouri swimming venue known for alcohol and dare-devil diving where nine people have died over the years. The lawsuit seeks to shut down the business, “Offsets”, as a public nuisance.
Hawley acknowledges he doesn’t have criminal jurisdiction but says the civil suit has teeth. “This action is a significant one in that it would shut down this operation,” said Hawley. “There are various civil penalties, including damages, that could be assessed. So, we will continue to move forward.”
The Offsets by law has 30-days to respond to the lawsuit and has continued to operate in the interim.
Hawley claimed a major victory earlier this year when a St. Louis court tossed out an attempt by pharmaceutical companies to block his lawsuit against them. The complaint alleges Purdue Pharma, Endo Health, and Janssen Pharmaceuticals fraudulently misrepresented the serious risks posed by the drugs they manufacture and sell.
Within the state, the attorney general’s office is conducting a probe of all four Missouri Catholic dioceses after revelations of sexual abuse of children by clergy in Pensylvania. The dioceses submitted to the investigations voluntarily.
In August, Hawley brought a court case against the St. Louis Housing Authority and the company that manages the Clinton Peabody Housing Complex for failing to fix mold, infestations, and structural issues at the complex. Media outlets, including Missourinet, have reported on rodent infestation.
Hawley’s spokesperson, Mary Compton, says the Attorney General’s Office has roughly 40,000 matters before it at any given time.
National spotlight
Even though he’s a relative novice to public office, Hawley has jumped into several lawsuits with multiple attorneys general from other states that are politically charged. Many attorneys generals have given him high marks for his attempts to fight for Missourians against big corporations or the Federal Government.
The most high-profile case is a 20-state lawsuit led by Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, a fellow Republican which seeks to invalidate the Affordable Care Act. The health care law established under Democratic President Barack Obama has long been a target of the GOP.
Hawley says the lawsuit is meant to eliminate an intrusive regulation. “The intent is to prevent the government from telling people what they can and cannot do with their healthcare,” Hawley said. “The intent is to free folks from the burden of Obamacare.”
Senator McCaskill has based much of her reelection campaign on preserving the requirement to cover pre-existing conditions and has hammered Hawley over the lawsuit. But Republican leaders, including the attorneys general from those states say that pre-existing conditions would be preserved.
Hawley says he favors keeping the provision for preexisting conditions in place and claims it can be done while still doing away with Obamacare.
Watching over Jefferson City
Hawley performance in pursuing wrongdoing with within state government draws differing responses depending who’s being asked.
He’s has investigated former Republican Governor Eric Greitens several times. One of the probes led to felony charges in St. Louis after Hawley said he found evidence Greitens had used a donor list from a charity that he founded to raise money for his 2016 campaign.
Other investigations into the controversy-plagued former governor were inconclusive. Hawley investigated Greitens’ social media for alleged Sunshine Law violations three times and the governor’s use of the Confide text erasing app.
Each time his office said a lack of jurisdiction or subpoena power contributed to dropping the inquiry or clearing Greitens of wrongdoing. Hawley took heat from Democrats, especially over the Confide investigation after he reported no evidence of wrongdoing.
Hawley’s office likewise found no evidence of wrongdoing by Democratic State Auditor Nicole Galloway or her office in a similar investigation. In Hawley’s probes, senior staff in both offices were interviewed.
As the state’s chief legal officer, many argue Hawley has been productive for Missourians. With many of these big cases behind him, he’s finally been hitting the campaign trail to a greater extent heading toward the election.
That much to relief to republicans who see the McCaskill seat as a pick-up.